Klaviyo’s textual content messaging service was surprisingly in style in an anecdotal examine of fifty direct-to-consumer manufacturers. The evaluate additionally discovered that the majority manufacturers used pop-ups to seize emails however didn’t seem to make use of a welcome collection.
I just lately researched how DTC manufacturers deploy e mail advertising and marketing. I created a listing of firms utilizing Jasper’s AI chat and Google search. I then selected websites haphazardly from every supply.
I signed up for every model’s e mail utilizing the shape on its dwelling web page and a free AOL e mail handle for this objective. I used BuiltWith to find out a model’s e mail service supplier.
I accessed every DTC web site simply as soon as. However many had A/B testing software program put in in keeping with BuiltWith, indicating I might need skilled a unique sign-up course of on subsequent visits.
Whereas it’s not scientific, reviewing these DTC web sites uncovered 4 patterns: the widespread use of textual content messaging, ubiquitous pop-ups, intensive incentives, and a scarcity of welcome sequence messages.
Model | URL | Incentive | Textual content | Pop-up | ESP |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
Cuts Clothes | https://www.cutsclothing.com/ | Sure | Sure | Sure | Klaviyo |
Marc’s Magic Rub | https://marcsmagicrub.com/ | No | No | No | MailChimp |
Pulp Pantry | https://pulppantry.com/ | Sure | Sure | Sure | Klaviyo |
DEUX | https://www.eatdeux.com/ | No | Sure | Sure, however textual content | Klaviyo |
The Ridge | https://ridge.com/ | No | No | No | Klaviyo |
MUDWTR | https://mudwtr.com/ | No | Sure | Sure | Klaviyo |
Feastables | https://feastables.com/ | No | Sure | Sure | Klaviyo |
Blueland | https://www.blueland.com/ | Sure | Sure | Sure | Klaviyo |
G FUEL | https://gfuel.com/ | Sure | Sure | Sure | Klaviyo |
Cometeer | https://cometeer.com/ | No | Sure | Sure | Klaviyo |
Biossance | https://biossance.com/ | Sure | Sure | No | Klaviyo |
Ten Little | https://tenlittle.com/ | No | No | No | Klaviyo |
Appointed | https://appointed.co/ | Sure | Sure | Sure | Klaviyo |
Caraway | https://www.carawayhome.com/ | Sure | Sure | Sure | Klaviyo |
JuneShine | https://juneshine.com/ | No | Sure | Sure | Klaviyo |
Trace | https://www.drinkhint.com/ | No | Sure | Sure | Klaviyo |
Lovevery | https://lovevery.com/ | No | No | Sure | MailChimp |
Allbirds | https://www.allbirds.com/ | Sure | No | Sure | Iterable |
Saatva | https://www.saatva.com/ | No | Sure | Sure | MailChimp |
Peloton | https://www.onepeloton.com/ | No | No | No | Customized |
Quip | https://www.getquip.com/ | Sure | Sure | Sure | MailChimp |
Outer | https://liveouter.com/ | Sure | Sure | Sure | Klaviyo |
Nutrafol | https://nutrafol.com/ | Sure | Sure | Sure | Different |
Away | https://www.awaytravel.com/ | Sure | No | No | Different |
Warby Parker | https://www.warbyparker.com/ | No | No | No | Different |
Casper | https://casper.com/ | No | No | No | Different |
Beltology | https://www.beltology.com/ | Sure | No | Sure | Klaviyo |
Bombas | https://bombas.com/ | Sure | Sure | Sure | Different |
MVMT | https://www.mvmt.com/ | Sure | Sure | Sure | Different |
Stance | https://www.stance.com/ | No | No | No | Klaviyo |
WP Commonplace | https://wpstandard.com/ | Sure | No | Sure | Klaviyo |
ROKA | https://www.roka.com/ | Sure | Sure | Sure | Different |
Pura Vida | https://www.puravidabracelets.com/ | Sure | Sure | Sure | Klaviyo |
American Large | https://www.american-giant.com/ | Sure | Sure | Sure | Klaviyo |
AYR | https://www.ayr.com/ | Sure | Sure | Sure | Klaviyo |
Bonobos | https://bonobos.com/ | No | No | No | Different |
Buck Mason | https://www.buckmason.com/ | No | No | Sure | Klaviyo |
Combatant Gents | https://combatgent.com/ | Sure | No | Sure | Klaviyo |
Cuyana | https://www.cuyana.com/ | Sure | Sure | Sure | NetSuite |
Fame and Companions | https://www.fameandpartners.com/ | No | No | Sure | Klaviyo |
Frank and Oak | https://www.frankandoak.com/ | Sure | Sure | Sure | MailChimp |
Indochino | https://www.indochino.com/ | Sure | Sure | Sure | Different |
KUIU | https://www.kuiu.com/ | Sure | No | Sure | Klaviyo |
Wohven | https://wohven.com/ | Sure | Sure | Sure | Klaviyo |
Tracksmith | https://www.tracksmith.com/ | Sure | No | Sure | Klaviyo |
Chubbies | https://www.chubbiesshorts.com/ | Sure | Sure | Sure | Klaviyo |
HVMN | https://hvmn.com/ | Sure | Sure | Sure | Different |
Ora | https://www.ora.natural/ | No | No | No | Klaviyo |
ArtLifting | https://www.artlifting.com/ | No | No | Sure | MailChimp |
Hubble | https://www.hubblecontacts.com/ | No | No | No | Klaviyo |
Klaviyo Driving Textual content Messaging
Of the 50 DTC ecommerce websites, 31 used Klaviyo for e mail advertising and marketing.
Shopify invested $100 million in Klaviyo in 2022, so it’s not stunning that each Klaviyo web site additionally used Shopify. What’s stunning is a whopping 80% of Klayivo websites requested for my cell quantity. Of the 19 manufacturers not utilizing Klaviyo, 4 requested for my cell quantity, bringing the overall of text-seekers to 29 out of fifty.
Cuts, a DTC attire retailer, gives a 15% low cost for offering a cell quantity.
This doesn’t imply that any manufacturers are amassing cell numbers, however they definitely need them. One model, Deux (cookie dough), requested for my cell quantity in a pop-up however not my e mail handle. To subscribe by e mail, I needed to discover the shape within the footer.

Duex requested for a cell quantity in a pop-up however not an e mail handle.
DTC manufacturers use textual content messages like e mail, together with delivery and supply notifications, promotional gives, deserted cart reminders, and comparable. The distinction is in responsiveness. Whereas they typically have a number of e mail addresses and obtain many emails day by day, buyers usually have only one cell phone and obtain a lot fewer textual content messages. Thus those self same buyers are often extra conscious of cell communications, not less than for now.
Even earlier than reviewing these 50 websites, I used to be satisfied that textual content messaging was a prime alternative for ecommerce firms. Now it might be crucial.
Pop-ups Rule
Regardless of experiences that buyers dislike them, pop-ups appeared on 38 of the 50 on-line shops.
Some pop-ups appeared the moment my browser loaded. Others waited for me to scroll. Usually the pop-ups loaded on a number of screens, that means I needed to work together with them as much as 4 occasions — requesting my e mail handle, my cell quantity, and why I visited.

Thirty-eight out of fifty DTC shops used pop-ups. This instance is from Bombas, the attire model.
Most Provide an Incentive
The following development was that many of the DTC manufacturers provided an incentive to subscribe to e mail advertising and marketing. Twenty-nine of the 50 provided a reduction, free delivery, or an opportunity to win one thing. Allbirds even provided an opportunity to win a trip to New Zealand!
One of the best incentive expertise got here from websites that supplied a coupon code in the identical subscription pop-up. Kuiu, a vendor of looking gear, added my coupon code to the web site’s header — prepared to make use of at checkout. That was the most effective expertise of any of the websites I visited.
Electronic mail Welcome Collection
Once I got down to evaluate the DTC websites, I used to be most within the e mail welcome collection.
So I signed up for the e-mail lists and waited. Then I waited extra.
Solely 4 of the manufacturers had welcome messages. Quip (electrical toothbrushes) put an e mail message within the AOL inbox the moment I clicked the subscribe backside. Frank and Oak (sustainable attire) and Kuiu delivered messages inside seconds. Roka (efficiency sun shades) emailed me twice within the first 20 minutes.
The 46 others took a very long time. After six hours, solely 25 had despatched a welcome message, together with many who had promised a coupon code to make use of on the primary order. The message from one of many 25 went to my spam folder.
Takeaways
My anecdotal examine of DTC manufacturers’ use of e mail advertising and marketing left me with three takeaways.
First, ecommerce companies ought to experiment with textual content messaging. It’s straightforward for DTC manufacturers utilizing Klaviyo so as to add a mobile-number-capture type to their web sites, but it surely doesn’t imply they execute it properly. Thus implementing a textual content message plan will help sustain with a competitor and even outperform, maybe utilizing a text-specific software to facilitate gross sales along with sending hyperlinks.
Second, use a pop-up with a transparent incentive. If these DTC manufacturers are indicative, pop-ups are well worth the friction.
Third, there’s a chance to have interaction with new subscribers through welcome e mail collection. Roughly half of the examined manufacturers don’t use one.